The story of WordPress would be incomplete without acknowledging the page builder and plugin eco-system that exists in WordPress. Page builders after all are what really catapulted this CMS as a serious contender for developing and maintaining all kinds of websites. Selecting a page builder is a practical question that comes up when you are creating a new WordPress site and for a lot of people this means making a choice that will define the way their site is built and later managed. Two of the top contenders in this space are:
- Elementor which can be installed as a plugin
- Gutenberg Block Builder which is built inside WordPress as the default editor (since version 5.0)
There are some other very good page builders available as well, however this article looks only at these two as they appear to have the largest user base. Both are legitimate and strong contenders and offer different advantages. The best way to choose, apart from your own development skills, is to look at what you are trying to achieve in your site build.
The short and simple answer
- Elementor is easier to use but results in a vendor locked setup with inevitable compromise on speed and DOM complexity.
- Gutenberg generally results in faster sites and carries much lesser recurring costs in terms of licenses for addons.
- Choose the tool based on your skill and needs. If you feel overwhelmed then get in touch with us to help you build your website/page using the best approach for your specific needs.
Building for speed
This is an area where one can see some real differences in the two page builders. Sites built with Gutenberg generally render faster than ones built with Elementor. This obviously assumes that both are used to build the same kind of page and no caching is used. The difference is not just in the amount of styling css and javascript code/libraries but the DOM structure of a page built with Gutenberg is also usually simpler and has less nesting. This kind of built in optimization gives the block editor a headstart in terms of needing any kind of finetuning/advanced caching. A detailed analysis of the speed comparison can also be seen here which confirms with our own observations too.
Accessibility and long-term site maintenance
Websites today need to be made accessible to people who browse the internet differently due to any physical or even any situational disability. This is akin to installing ramps or elevators in a building so a store can be reached by as many people as possible. While accessibility certainly has to be “baked” in a website as it is built, the Gutenberg block editor generally makes it easier to do so. A page built using the block editor contains substantially less wrapper markup and the underlying code is usually more semantically consistent. While Elementor does provide an accessibility assistant the tool only comes with the paid Elementor One plan. Gutenberg on the other hand can be paired with some free options available as plugins to get similar results.
This also brings out the long term site maintenance cost as the native block editor can be paired with a far greater number of addon plugins (both free and paid) as compared to Elementor. A more open eco-system means a more competitive market resulting in lower costs for widget/block addons. Something as simple as a post type loop is only available in the pro version of Elementor while it is built as a native block in Gutenberg and quite a few more advanced query loop plugins are also available in the WordPress repository.
Design control and developer/user friendliness
This is an area where Elementor continues to shine and mostly outperform not just Gutenberg but many other builders too. It’s certainly easier for a user to drag and drop an Elementor widget, style its options (colors, backgrounds, border, animation effects and so on) and get an easy to use tree view as well as a design view of the page. While the block editor plays catch up with Elementor,it is still fair to consider Elementor a superior solution when it comes to a user converting their design vision to a working page.
The growing maturity of block editor addons has closed some of the gap. The latest block editor now already provides custom styling and visibility options on blocks.
Cost of ownership
Gutenberg and Elementor are both free in their basic forms. However, whereas you can quickly run into the need for paid addons and pro version for Elementor, you can go much farther with the free options/addons available for Gutenberg. Even if a paid addon is needed then there are some options available for lifetime licenses of addons for Gutenberg. Elementor addons are usually priced per year which can result in higher recurring costs.
On top of this there is the question of vendor lock in. Gutenberg stores your content as normal HTML with additional markup stored as comments thus avoiding the convoluted nested DOM structure of Elementor. Switching over to a different page builder or even a different CMS would be far easier with the block editor as compared to Elementor.
Market Share
This is where Elementor has a pretty good lead. As a page builder that came out in 2016 it was obviously everyone’s choice for quite a while before Gutenberg started to ship as a serious contender. It is also the easier of the two page builders for people to learn and start using. All this means that Elementor seems to have a far larger share of the WordPress page builder market and is certainly past the “fad” stage. It’s a serious contender for any site build and there are times when it should certainly be considered as the best choice to build a site.
Our own preference
While we have experience in building and maintaining websites using all kind of page builders (in addition to Elementor and Gutenberg our team has built sites using Divi, SiteOrigin, WP Bakery, Avada Website Builder and more) our current preference is to build WordPress sites using the Gutenberg block editor.
Why is Gutenberg our choice for almost all new WordPress site builds?
- The block editor has now reached a stage of refinement and stability where it is a serious contender.
- The development and end user experience is now much smoother.
- At the end of the day your page has to load quickly and the block editor wins that race more often than not.
- Most features are provided in the core thus negating the need for any more paid plugin bloat. A lean website always works out better in the long run.
- No long term vendor lock-in involved. Switching to something else is usually less problematic.